Thought Papers

Natural Environment Bill – Implications for the consultation

This thought paper examines the Scottish Government’s handling of the consultation process, particularly in light of the recently published Natural Environment Bill. It argues that the process was flawed, failing to meet established consultation standards, and that the government undermined its own consultation by introducing significant legislative changes immediately after it closed. The Bill alters key aspects of how National Parks are managed, yet these changes were not disclosed during the consultation. This has led to accusations of manipulation, lack of transparency, and disregard for public input.

National Parks and the Natural Environment Bill

Following the publication of the Scottish Government’s Natural Environment Bill, this thought paper examines the proposed changes to National Park legislation and the implications of introducing these after the closure of NatureScot’s consultation on the proposed Galloway National Park.

You can read the Bill and find more information at: https://www.gov.scot/news/restoring-scotlands-natural-environment/

Campaigning in the Age of Misinformation

This thought paper reflects on the campaign for the proposed Galloway National Park, examines the challenges posed by misinformation and the efforts to counter it.

Delving into the Issues - Part II

Further to the thought paper published in December 2024, which outlined significant concerns about the Consultation process, this thought paper explores further issues regarding the Consultation.

Local Representative or Puppet

This thought paper examines the governance of National Parks and highlights how it could serve as a mechanism for extending central government control in the Park boundary

Conservation or Consumption

This thought paper explores the apparent contradiction of promoting conservation while simultaneously increasing consumption, through tourism and recreation

Consultation Issues

This thought paper investigates the role of NatureScot as the Scottish Government Reporter, questioning its ability to remain impartial. It also examines the shortcomings of the consultation process to date

Views of expert Roger Crofts

This thought paper highlights the contributions of expert Roger Crofts to the National Park debate and directs you to some of his articles, which delve into various issues surrounding the proposals